Why become concentric?

Hello!

I used Noise Distortion on each single circle in a filter. There are some circles on top of each other. If I make this pattern seamless, the circles become concentric. I dislike it. How can I dissolve this problem?

Non-seamless:

The difference looks better on this:

Thank you for idea. Unfortunately it looks very different that I want. They are concentric again.

Test

Here's another way to do it

Oh yes, the good old origin and bomber trick, of course emme, you nailed it! My Sunday stumbling, but learning to use the loop is helpful too. Blame xirja if you must.

It is an optional sub-node of the loop:

Perhaps you'd like to create a new thread/post to address whatever issue you are having with the loop component?

non seamless:

emme's sequence:

Hmm, it seems like you are inputting a static image into the color of the free ellipses. That input wont move with the x/y origin of the ellipse, so the ellipse is just acting as a mask - blocking out part of the input image. You could use the bombers center x/y sub-components to offset the input image accordingly. I dont really think you need to use image input here though - you can just use a single color per ellipse to build up the shapes.

Also you might want to limit the min/max settings of the randomizers, so that the ellipses wont move too much.

You can check my settings here:

CircleBomber v001.ffxml

I have just found this thread looking to make non concentric circles in FF, as it is very easy to make concentric ones, but to have random offset of the circles is not so easy to find out, and with great and very useful help of xirja and emme I have seen a great way to do it and will try

Thanks also to Janeway for asking this question

Here is what I want to do, use the bomber plus with randomizer and loops to make this art that is based on the PI Feynman point art

and not only in a rectangle also in a circle way

Using an archimedean spiral (with approximately equidistant spacing)

ArchimedeanSpiral v001.ffxml