YOUR ACCOUNT

Login or Register to post new topics or replies
Lucato
FF addicted

Posts: 505
Filters: 39
Hi folks, here goes my first wish. I'm not sure if It can be accomplished, anyway here I go:

Now a days when creating a filter/texture in the Filter Editor, the construction is from the left to right in the workspace. (Like those countries where people read from right to left). I think It would be useful to have a checkbox in the tools|options, where we would be able to check "[ ] Make links from left to right". So we would build the components from left to right. When checked this checkbox the nodes would become a kind of flip horizontal how they are today. I mean, the nodes would have the thumbs on the right and the options texts on the left. So, the big green arrow would be on the right and the small ones on the left side to get to built from LEFT to RIGHT.

For the far future maybe also from TOP to BOTTOM. smile;)

Cheers,
Lucato.
  Details E-Mail
Vladimir Golovin
Administrator
Posts: 3446
Filters: 55
Quote
Lucato wrote:
"[ ] Make links from left to right".


Heh. I spent almost two weeks prototyping this. I did quite a lot of mockups, and the guys did a real working prototype with left-to-right links.

It just felt wrong. Not that I'm saying that the current right-to-left scheme is perfect and all, but the prototype just didn't feel right. I started to suspect that this feel was just because it was unusual to me after 1.5 years of right-to-left connections -- so I tried to drop my right-to-left customs, and worked only in the new prototype for a week.

To cut the long story short, I decided to keep the current scheme you see in the beta -- because to make left-to-right connections work, we would need to remove the Result component.

When I removed the Result component from the prototype, it felt just like writing. But with the Result component in the tree, it felt very, very unnatural -- the Result stays on the right, and you're building the component tree leftwards!
  Details E-Mail
Vladimir Golovin
Administrator
Posts: 3446
Filters: 55
Here's a screen from that prototype:

  Details E-Mail
Lucato
FF addicted

Posts: 505
Filters: 39
Hi Vladimir, I'm sorry for my delay, but I'm quite busy lately.

Yup!!!!! That is what I was talking about!!!! Please Add this option!!!! p p p p p p please. I didn't get to undestand why you said"because to make left-to-right connections work, we would need to remove the Result component.". Anyway, I'm not sure if what I'll say has some sence, but maybe you could make:

- The Result Componet floats like those sites where the menu follows you when scrolling the screen. So, when dragging the workarea the RC would follow the screen... or...
- The Result Componet would automatically move to right after each new node added... or...
- Better, we would pick with right click in the context menu an option "Add Result Component (Finish)". So, when you decide to apply a resul you just do It in the moment you want to.

Well, I'm not a developer, just suggestions. smile;)

I really hope the left-to-right would be implemented.

Thanks for the feedback and the image preview.

A hug,
Lucato.
  Details E-Mail
nemo
Posts: 6
Seconded - it should be a configuration option. (And you don't need to lose the result component!)
  Details E-Mail
uberzev
not lyftzev

Posts: 1890
Filters: 36
Thirded! smile:D
  Details E-Mail
Lucato
FF addicted

Posts: 505
Filters: 39
Quote
Seconded - it should be a configuration option

Yup, that was what I said in the beginning: "It would be useful to have a checkbox in the tools|options, where we would be able to check "[ ] Make links from left to right"



  Details E-Mail
Lucato
FF addicted

Posts: 505
Filters: 39
Still talking about that, other interesting stuff would be to get to drag and slide the Output (Big Green Arrow) all around the node and release in the position we want to. Well, not really needed, but would be interesting. smile;)
  Details E-Mail
Vladimir Golovin
Administrator
Posts: 3446
Filters: 55
Quote
Lucato wrote:
"because to make left-to-right connections work, we would need to remove the Result component.".


This isn't a technical difficulty but a usability issue. As long as the Result is in the tree, the left-to-right "writing" metaphor isn't going to work. I tried hard, but it just didn't feel right.
  Details E-Mail
Lucato
FF addicted

Posts: 505
Filters: 39
Accomplished wish! smile;)

Congratulations Vlad and FF team for getting to solve that and for implementing it in the Filter Forge 1.004. Now I feel much better using left-to-right. For those that don't feel well working in that way, don't worry. It can be changed in Tools/Option/Filter Editor.

Thanks!
  Details E-Mail

Join Our Community!

Filter Forge has a thriving, vibrant, knowledgeable user community. Feel free to join us and have fun!

33,711 Registered Users
+18 new in 30 days!

153,531 Posts
+39 new in 30 days!

15,347 Topics
+72 new in year!

Create an Account

Online Users Last minute:

21 unregistered users.